DFA Guide to Dublin- A Keen Web Page Indeed
DFA Guide to Dublin!


What is Mick Halpin up to Now?!
Current Diatribe


Critical Mick Index

Index
| FAQ's | Interviews
Full Index | Irish Crime


Recent Reviews!
Critical Mick Review of Mary, Mary by Julie Parsons
Mary, Mary by Julie Parsons


Critical Mick Review of Utterly Monkey by Nick Laird
Utterly Monkey by Nick Laird

When you do your shopping via the links below, Amazon makes a donation to this site without affecting your purchase price.

Support Critical Mick!
Support Critical Mick!


Support Critical Mick!
Fellow DFA's! I need your support, too!



NFG Magazine- Writing With Attitude!
NFG Magazine- Highly Recommended


Books Ireland Magazine- News and Reviews
Books Ireland- Also Highly Recommended

Other Review Sites!
Critical Mick Index
The Midwest Book Review

Critical Mick

Reviews Free of Rules.

Reviews by the Clown that All Other Critics Want to Strangle with a Black Turtleneck

Scaredy Cat, by Mark Billingham.  Just finished by Critical Mick.

Scaredy Cat Edgy enough London crime! Says Mick .mp3 (3.62 MB)
Mark Billingham
Time Warner Paperbacks, 2003

http://www.markbillingham.com/

 

The Bright, Refined Psychopaths of Popular Fiction Can Kiss Our Asses

The paperback rack at the local supermarket is well stocked with titles from Mark Billingham's Detective Inspector Tom Thorne series. Having dipped into Paul Carson's Dublin, I decided to see how London-based crime compared.

Scaredy Cat follows a small band of detectives as they pursue the killers of several young women. Led by an ornery sonovabitch, they discover the roots of the murders intertwine with the love and cruelty of three childhood outcasts, twenty years past.

When I was trying to form a picture of DI Tom Thorne, the actor Trevor Eve kept crashing the auditions. That's not fair. Eve already has his own highly recommended cop show, Waking the Dead. He should have let some other cocky, independent middle-aged whitey play Tom Thorne, but who did I see in every one of the losing-the-temper-at-his-co-workers scenes? Trevor Eve. Who sympathetically convinced the freshly orphaned three year old to speak, with Shakespearean authority? Eve again. Greedy bastard.

Hi, I'm Johnny Cash. As mentioned in Mark Billingham's novel Scaredy Cat

Thorne's circle of cops contains interesting characters. They're younger and edgier than most. Thorne's best friend, for example, is a gay dude who is into piercing and cutting up dead bodies. There's also gratuitous cocaine use and one of the detectives is a bit of a ho. Scaredy Cat also delves into well-researched forensic gore and the dark, dark world of Johnny Cash. Johnny Cash? Yep, Johnny Cash.

Mark Billingham's other claim to fame comes from the stand-up comedy circuit, but Scaredy Cat contains less humor than I expected. Thorne's nemesis is the sharp corner of a desk in the incident room, sure enough, and there is an absolutely gag-worthy urban legend about the biscuits eaten in British public schools. That aside, Billingham keeps his worlds well divided. Carl Hiaasen and Janet Evanovich belong in a different rack altogether. Maybe even in a different store.

One complaint: the blurb on the back. A major twist is given away, straight out. "Mark Billingham's gripping thriller has a unique twist. In this mystery DI Tom Thorne is not in search of just a serial killer but two - working in tandem." Unique? Maybe to someone who's never heard of Kiss the Girls. I picked Scaredy Cat up because of the reviews, then spent the first wedge of chapters pissed off because I knew exactly what twist was coming.

Another complaint: the killer was easy to spot. The last half of Scaredy Cat centers around the question, "what colleague, privy to details of the investigation, is actually our twisted childhood killer all grown up?" It could go several ways, so the true identity keeps readers guessing. Linda La Plante has done the same, though not in her finest work.

Um... no.  Mark Billingham's novel Scaredy Cat contains real baddies, commiting real sins.

Moan moan moan, complain complain complain.

The verdict: Mark Billingham's characters and approach are a step above most procedurals. The notion behind his latest installment, Lifeless, sounds interesting. I might pick that up next trip to the local supermarket. Or order it from markbillingham.com, where interesting information is well presented. There are even links to video clips of the author plugging his work. Cool stuff! But is it as cool as mickhalpin.com? NO!

Nowhere on Billingham's site can visitors find a pic of Joan Collins.

Twenty years ago, Critical Mick was a schoolyard outcast. But he did not grow up into a psycho like in Scaredy Cat. And he DEFINITELY never ate a public school biscuit.

And now for an important disclaimer from Critical Mick

Yo! This review and all content on the DFA Guide site are copyright 2005 Mick Halpin. All links to other sites and documents are copyright to whatever source wrote something cool enough for Mick to give it a referral. Try to claim them as your own work and bad karma will catch up with you, baby. Believe it.

Irate, huh? Managed to piss off another one? Direct your hatemail to mick @ mickhalpin dot com.


This Page Was Last Updated On 31 December, 2005.

What is Mick up to? | Who Is Mick? | See Why He's a Sap
Hire Him! | Or His Various Diatribes |
Or Some Things You Should Know About Dublin |