DFA Guide to Dublin- A Keen Web Page Indeed
DFA Guide to Dublin!


What is Mick Halpin up to Now?!
Current Diatribe


Critical Mick Index

Index
| FAQ's | Interviews
Full Index | Irish Crime


Featured Reviews!
Critical Mick Review of Lake of Sorrows by Erin Hart
Lake of Sorrows by Erin Hart


Critical Mick Review of 24/7 by Susan DiPlacido
24/7 by Susan DiPlacido


Critical Mick Review of Song for Katya by Kevin Stevens
Song for Katya by Kevin Stevens


Critical Mick Review of Death in the Desert by Francine Biere
Death in the Desert by Francine Biere

When you do your shopping via the links below, Amazon makes a donation to this site without affecting your purchase price.

Support Critical Mick!
Support Critical Mick!


Support Critical Mick!
Fellow DFA's! I need your support, too!



NFG Magazine- Writing With Attitude!
NFG Magazine- Highly Recommended


Books Ireland Magazine- News and Reviews
Books Ireland- Also Highly Recommended


The Dublin Quarterly: International Literary Review
The Dublin Quarterly

Other Review Sites!
Midwest Book Review- Jim Cox Rocks
The Midwest Book Review


Reviewing the Evidence- Mystery Reviews, and a Cat
Reviewing the Evidence

Podcasts Worth A Listen!
Escape Pod- Short Fiction. From Weirdo Imaginations, Straight to Your Ears
Escape Pod


writingshow.com, Paula B's weekly interviews about elephants. NO!  LIES!  About writing.
The Writing Show

Mick's Fave Bookstores
Read Ireland- Clicks and Mortar, plus a whole lot more
Read Ireland


Mystery Ink, The Mystery Bookstore.
Mystery Ink
15 Dawson Street
Dublin 2

Critical Mick

Reviews Free of Rules.

Reviews by the Clown that All Other Critics Want to Strangle with a Black Turtleneck

Nominations for the best book Critical Mick read in 2008


   Critical Mick Best Book Read in 2008


 

Critical Mick's shortlist for Best Book Read in 2008...

Critical Mick Review of In the Woods by Tana French

 

In the Woods by Tana French
Critical Mick Review of Black Swan Green by David Mitchell

 

Black Swan Green by David Mitchell
Critical Mick Review of Run by Douglas E. Winter

 

Run by Douglas E. Winter
Critical Mick Review of The Road to McCarthy by Pete McCarthy

 

The Road to McCarthy by Pete McCarthy
Critical Mick Review of The Guilty Heart by Julie Parsons

 

The Guilty Heart by Julie Parsons

 

 

 

 

  • Books are added to the shortlist whenever they goddamned well move me to.
  • Every bugsmacker read in the year 2008 is eligible, regardless of its year of publication.
  • Rather than an Edgar, an Agatha, a Shamus, these Critical Mick Best Book Read awards are called an "Oo," as in "book" or "unrooly." You know, the sound made when impressed?
  • The awards look like this: and the year's winner gets to tattoo it on their foot.

  •  
     
     
     

    And the most unruly is...

    Critical Mick Review of Black Swan Green by David Mitchell

    Black Swan Green, by David Mitchell.

    2008: The Year in Unruly Review (still under construction....)

    The past year provided the opportunity to read thirty-three titles and interview nine authors, but the real highlight was being invited to moderate an Irish crime panel discussion called "Forty Shades of Grey: Real Fiction, Real Ireland" at the Sunday Independent's Books 2008 event in September. Meeting Gene Kerrigan, Ruth Dudley Edwards, Brian McGilloway, Arlene Hunt, and Declan Burke was an honor. The missus swears I didn't make too big of an eejit of myself, but she is just being kind.

    I am also grateful for an opportunity that passed me by. For some daft reason, RTE screen-tested me for a weekly book critic slot on their afternoon television program. I took a day off work and drove down to Donnybrook. Shaking hands with producers! Getting wired up for sound! Being told to stop looking into the very expensive-looking camera! Auditioning was a thrill that lasted the whole next week of waiting. Media celebrity was not for me in 2008, alas. I didn't even get to bonk anyone famous. But I did get the chance to stop and actually put into words why I wanted the job of telling people about stories.

    Rather than my usual annual "what I read," lemme share those answers with you. What would your own responses have been? It's harder than it seems to boil it down in to clear answers.

    Some of the books that Mick plans to read in 2009.

    Tell us, why are you a bookworm?

    Books are a conversation that can't be stopped by borders and years: characters, settings, topics, ideas. You can make a connection with someone who lived centuries ago, be more informed by their position, their observations and consequences. You can fill your own head with their thoughts, decide who you are by whether you agree or choose to make your own decision. You can be down and alone, pick up a book and discover- there's someone who was there before you. There's someone who has felt just the same.

    Besides, reading's a great escape. Lord of the Rings was the Fantasy that got me through my difficult years at school. There's millions who are in my same boots, well-adjusted adult veterans who stood facing the armies of Mordor. Where we were teenaged outcasts, we're now united.

    It's a big, absurd lonely world we all live in. Who wouldn't want to be informed and connected as possible?

    What is the best book you've ever read?

    Ever read? What's the best breath you've ever breathed? Let me narrow it down to a question more manageable, if you don't mind.

    So far this year the best book I have read is Black Swan Green. It's by an English writer named David Mitchell, about the same age as me, who's also now living here in Ireland I understand. He was short-listed for the Booker Prize twice, most recently for that book Cloud Atlas that everyone's raving about. But I wanted to go in to a novel that I knew absolutely nil about, no preconceived notions. From the very first chapter, this kid Jason Taylor living in the fictional midlands town of Black Swan Green, just knocked me out. In thirteen chapters that covered thirteen months of Taylor's life, Mitchell captured exactly what it's like to be twelve years old. This novel brings the truth and power of Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha into a time that I did not realize how well I remembered until seeing afresh. Damn.

    I maintain a list of the best books that I've read each year on my website, criticalmick.com. I even give out an annual award for the best one. It's called an "Oo," as in "book" or "unrooly." You know, the sound made when impressed?

    What genre/type of books do you like best and why?

    I'm loving this explosion in Irish crime fiction, the last several of years. The talent coming out of Ireland has been winning Edgar and Shaymus awards on the worldwide stage: Ken Bruen, Declan Hughes, Tana French.

    It's not only that I like seeing the goodies and baddies of the place I live- Ireland is the perfect location for crime. Unarmed cops, heavily armed baddies - Good booze, pub strangers who appear friendly - Caches of buried arms - Doorway to Europe, strong connections to... everywhere - New prosperity across the road from old poverty - Emigrants returning home... bringing what back? - Political fun! - Drop-dead gorgeous women - Savage tempers - Celtic heritage - Small island where chance meetings, wanted and unwanted, are a certainty - Major drug route into the UK - Poets, musicians, comedians and other lyrical, colorful bastards - Majestic backdrops - Rich history of injustices to dredge up - It's a place you thought you knew, but you're guaranteed to be surprised.

    Where and when do you like to read best?

    Bedtimes and beaches, but also cool mornings. Kevin Stevens wrote Song for Katya, a cold war romance that took place in Moscow. I would get up early, brew a big mug of scalding black coffee, and read it on the swing in my back garden. October in Ireland is not exactly Moscow, but the chill really fit. It really connected.

    And I remember, when I was new to this city, I'd take books on tape out of the Ilac Centre library. I'd have Brian Moore in my head and just walk for hours.

    I've always got a book in my hand and twenty or more tottering on my night table. There's few things better than sitting down, talking about them with any old body. Finding what you're read in common. Plugging the ones you've liked. Seeing what new perspectives th,Dan offer.

    What was the first book that made an impact on you?

    There was this short story making the rounds at my high school lunch table. "Oh! You've got to read this!" one of my buds came in saying, and passing on this battered copy of one of those Best American Short Stories anthologies from the 1980's. The next day, the friend who took it would come in raving, "There's this story about a mad teacher by Charles Baxter, this story called Gryphon. You've got to read it!"

    My turn came. I did more that sit down at the lunch table the next day saying "You've got to read this," After college I taught school for three years in one of the poorest parishes of Louisiana, in part because of that story.

    Peace

    Yer Friend Mick Halpin

     

    ...click to see who's in the running for Critical Mick Best Book Read in 2009


     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Past The Oo Award, given by Critical Mick to the Best Book Read that year. Winners
    The Last Place by Laura Lippman. Best book read in 2007 by Critical Mick Click for Critical Mick's 2007 Year in Unruly Review

    The Last Place's Tess Monaghan is a heroine of Buffy proportions, reinvigorating a stale genre- namely, serial killers- and taking Crime Fic somewhere it had never been before- Maryland!
     



     
    A Star Called Henry by Roddy Doyle. Best book read in 2006 by Critical Mick Click for Critical Mick's 2006 Year in Unruly Review

    This novel knocks into maggoty bits many inventions (dare Roddy say: fabrications) that have been guarded by long-standing Irish patents. Mad, wonderful and true.
     



     
    McCarthy's Bar by Pete McCarthy. Best book read in 2005 by Critical Mick Click for Critical Mick's 2005 Year in Unruly Review

    Don't take it from me, what it means to be Irish. Take it from Pete McCarthy's McCarthy's Bar. The dude rocks!
     



     
    Cosi Fan Tutti by Michael Dibdin. Best book read in 2004 by Critical Mick Best Book Critical Mick Read in 2004

    Michael Dibdin's Cosi Fan Tutti does for crime fiction what O Brother, Where Art Thou? did to The Great Depression. Classic!
     



     
    Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee. Best book read in 2003 by Critical Mick Best Book Critical Mick Read in 2003

    The truths and tragedies of Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee have remained vivid, even years later. Tattoo-worthy.

    And now for an important disclaimer from Critical Mick

    Yo! All content on the DFA Guide site are copyright 2008 Mick Halpin. All links to other sites and documents are copyright to whatever source wrote something cool enough for Mick to give it a referral. Try to claim them as your own work and bad karma will catch up with you, baby. Believe it.

    Irate, huh? Managed to piss off another one? Direct your hatemail to mick @ mickhalpin dot com.


    This Page Was Last Updated On 31 December, 2008.

    What is Mick up to? | Who Is Mick? | See Why He's a Sap
    Read His Various Diatribes | Or A Little About Computers
    Or Some Things You Should Know About Dublin |